Good. But noir way good as the original
As remakes of classic noir films go – and for my taste, most of them can’t go away fast enough – Hollywood's version of
NIGHT AND THE CITY
is entertaining enough, due mainly to snappy acting by veterans Jack
Warden, Cliff Gorman and Alan King (sadly, now all deceased) and some
role shuffling and plot simplification. But it ain’t noir or even
particularly noirish. Jules Dassin’s 42-year old version hit the noir
nail right on the head in mood and setting, but this version's director,
Irwin Winkler, clearly toadied to '90s tastes and probably committee
pressure by turning Harry Fabian, originally played by Richard Widmark
and in this version by Robert De Niro, from a rat into a likable and
well-meaning rascal, and switching the original ending from tragedy to
just this side of comedy. The black-and-white original you'll never
forget – the Technicolor remake,
fuhgetaboutit!
No comments:
Post a Comment